Beating Broke

Personal Finance from the Broke Perspective

The Irrationality of Seeking the Lowest Gas Price

By Leave a Comment

Seeking the Lowest Gas Prices

This week, I drove through the Costco parking lot, and I noticed that the usual entrance to the Costco gas station was blocked off. Instead, gas station traffic was diverted to the area by the entrance of Costco so a longer line could form and not block other parking lot traffic. I followed the line for gas and discovered it was at least 10 cars long. What?! What is this irrationality of seeking the lowest gas price? I am a Costco member, and yes, gas there can be up to 25 to 30 cents a gallon cheaper, but I would never wait in such a long line for gas.

Why do Americans obsessively attempt, at any cost, to pay the lowest gas price? Do they not know that their efforts cost them precious time and yes, even money?

One Woman’s Pursuit of the Lowest Gas Prices

I have a relative I will call Judy, who is a low gas price chaser. She will drive 10 miles or more out of her way to save a few pennies per gallon on the price of gas. She has a 10-gallon tank. If she pays $5.04 at her local gas station, filling her empty tank will cost $50.40.

If she cruises to a town 10 miles away, she might pay $4.98 per gallon, meaning a fill-up will cost $49.80. She saved .60 cents, but did she? She also wasted gas to get to the lower-priced station and took 20 to 30 minutes of her time to do so.

Why We Don’t Seek the Lowest Gas Price

I’m frugal in general. My husband and I only take our family out to eat about five times a year. We drive old vehicles. My Toyota Sienna is a 2004 and has 231,000 miles on it. My husband’s car is a 2013 and has 105,000 miles on it. We live in a modest neighborhood, and when we bought our house, we bought one that was on the lower end of what we could afford.

We like to save money, so you might be surprised to learn that I don’t play the lowest-gas-price game. It’s not worth it to me.

My minivan has a 20-gallon tank, and our nearest gas station sells gas for $4.86 a gallon. To fill up my minivan costs a whopping $97.20. Ouch! Gas at our nearest Costco is $4.55 a gallon. Filling up there would cost $91, so I would save $6.20. However, I do not want to wait in line for 30 to 45 minutes to save six bucks.

Seeking the Lowest Gas Prices

Instead, I choose to limit my driving while prices are so high. We stay home a lot more, and when we drive, we combine errands, so we don’t use as much gas. Right now, I’m filling up every two weeks.

Final Thoughts

Americans are obsessed with seeking the lowest gas price, only to save at most a few bucks, or, at worst, a few cents. To do so, they have to spend money and precious time. Rather than chasing the lowest gas price, a more lucrative option may be to find other frugal ways to save money that more significantly impacts their bottom line.

Read More

Why Buying a Toyota Sienna Was One of Our Best Decisions

Don’t Make the Cost of Gas Your Scapegoat

Is a Costco Membership Worth It When Living Alone?

Guaranteed Ways to Go Broke

By 1 Comment

How to Go Broke

If you look, you can find plenty of material about how to create a budget, save for retirement, and live within your means.  What you don’t find are many examples of people doing just that and living a financially solvent life.  On the other hand, you don’t find much material about guaranteed ways to go broke, but you can likely find people from all walks of life who flaunt the steps to going broke.  Ironically, those are often the people of whom we are most envious. [Read more…]

Why It’s Okay to Make Financial Mistakes

By 1 Comment

What’s the worst financial mistake you’ve made?  Ask any adult, and you’ll likely hear about thousand dollar or even hundreds of thousands of dollar mistakes.  Ouch.  We’d all love to go through life with a great handle on our money, only making smart decisions and watching our money grow in investment accounts.  But life isn’t that way.  Sometimes we’re just stupid with money, and other times, we think we’re making a smart decision only to find out later that we were wrong.  But that’s okay.  In fact, there are many reasons why it’s okay to make financial mistakes.

Why It's Okay to Make Financial Mistakes

Why It’s Okay to Make Financial Mistakes

Chances are you’re more financially savvy because of the mistakes you’ve made!

You Learn

The most important reason why it’s okay to make financial mistakes is that you learn from those mistakes.

When I was in my early 20s and just out of college, I was working at a job and was told that I would be getting a raise in the next few weeks.  I increased my meager standard of living because I knew the raise was in the works.  But week after week went by, and I didn’t get the raise.  In fact, a few months later, the company went out of business.  Not only was I out of a job, but I had accrued some debt by raising my lifestyle prematurely.

A few years ago, my husband was guaranteed a raise.  It was supposed to come in August, but it didn’t actually come until December.  Thanks to the lesson I learned in my 20s, we were very careful to avoid lifestyle creep.

You Can Help Others

When you’ve learned from your financial mistakes, you can help others avoid the same mistakes that you made.

Why It's Okay to Make Financial Mistakes
Photo by Irina Murza on Unsplash

When I went to graduate school, I did my best to avoid student loans.  I chose a college that paid my tuition and gave me a small stipend for teaching two classes a semester.  But after I graduated, I wanted to teach at a community college.  Those full-time jobs are inaccessible if you don’t have experience.  The only way to get experience is to teach as a part-timer, and part-time community college jobs pay next to nothing (about $1,000 for a 16 week class).

I went into credit card debt trying to maintain my college lifestyle (which was already frugal) while earning poverty level income.  The next year, I did get a full-time community college job, but I entered that job with over ten thousand dollars in credit card debt thanks to trying to subsist on such a low income.

When it comes to encouraging my kids to save and plan for college, I urge them to try to get scholarships that will also help them pay their living expenses.  We’re sending my son to SAT prep classes so he can score high enough to be in the running for a lucrative scholarship from our local college.

Final Thoughts

Making money mistakes is part of your history.  Hopefully, you’ve grown and made smarter decisions because of your financial mistakes, which is an excellent reason why it’s okay to make financial mistakes.

However, if you find yourself making the same mistakes over and over again, i.e. running up your credit cards, paying them down, and then running them up again, you may need to explore more deeply why you keep following the same negative behavior patterns.